Let's be real — though a vital solution to environmental justice and environmental action . . . not all policies are good. We'll dive into two policies that were unsuccessful, and key in on why these failed and how policies should be improved.
Kyoto Protocol
In case you didn't know, the Kyoto Protocol was THE first international treaty that set out to minimize carbon emissions. Though adopted in 1997, it was short-lived . . .
"The Protocol called for thirty-eight states to reduce greenhouse gases emissions to 5 percent below their emission levels in 1990 between 2008 and 2012. However, the United States never ended up ratifying the agreement and Canada withdrew from the Protocol days prior to the end of the first commitment period." (Columbia Political Review)
The Kyoto Protocol was split into Annex B and non-Annex B. Only states classified as Annex B were given quantifiable reduction targets; the non-Annex B states only had to cooperate with Annex B states for technological, educational, and research purposes.
But the Annex B states weren't chosen randomly — they were the highest emitters at the time. This is important, since it acknowledges that not all places were equally responsible for emissions.
Some people believe that the treaty did not include enough of, or the appropriate, Annex B participants. This is especially true since the US and Canada backed out and China (previously categorized as "underdeveloped") later became one of the highest emitters.
So the Kyoto Protocol was a success in that it was the first international climate agreement, but its foundation and the fact that people backed out caused its effectiveness to decline rapidly.
The Paris Agreement succeeded the Kyoto Protocol, but unfortunately that also didn't work as hoped . . .
Paris Agreement
"The Paris Agreement is a legally binding international treaty on climate change adopted by nearly 200 nations on December 12, 2015, at COP21 in Paris, France" (UNFCCC).
The Paris Agreement set out to hold the "increase in the global average temperature to well below 2°C above pre-industrial levels" and to "limit the temperature increase to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels."
And the truth?
We're not going to be able to achieve our goal of staying below 2° at the rate that we're going right now.
The first (and really important) reason is because our political leaders constantly change — and with their arrival, they bring different goals. Unfortunately, climate change isn't often one of the goals on their minds . . .
Under the second Donald Trump administration, the US backed out (again) of this other climate agreement.
The thing is, even if we do later get back on track with the agreement, it may be too late. We're already behind on our agreement . . .
The second reason why the Paris Agreement is not working is because its goals aren't binding enough.
If there was one good thing about the Kyoto Protocol, it would be that it had specific goals. The Paris Agreement's specific emissions targets themselves aren't legally binding and rely on timely updates rather than mandatory penalties.
Considering the way we're handling emissions right now, that's not good . . .
Summary
The main reason why both these treaties and agreements didn't work is simply because we don't have strict enough regulations and people powerful enough to enforce these treaties. For the Kyoto Protocol that meant that it was easy for countries to back out, and for the Paris Agreement that meant that there weren't specific enough goals.
Keeping this in mind, future policymakers and voters should both work together to ensure that we reach our goals to fix climate change, before it gets more out of hand than it already is . . .
References
Why the Paris Agreement failed climate change. (2026). World Politics Review. https://www.worldpoliticsreview.com/why-the-paris-agreement-failed-climate-change/
Kyotastrophe: The Kyoto Protocol's inequitable foundation. (2015, May 8). Columbia Political Review. https://www.cpreview.org/articles/2015/05/kyotastrophe-the-kyoto-protocols-inequitable
Bassetti, F. (2022, December 8). Success or failure? The Kyoto Protocol's troubled legacy. Foresight. https://www.climateforesight.eu/articles/success-or-failure-the-kyoto-protocols-troubled-legacy/
UNFCCC. (2025). The Paris Agreement. United Nations Climate Change. https://unfccc.int/process-and-meetings/the-paris-agreement
Banner image credit: Harvard Extension School